Page 2 of 2

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Tue Feb 07, 2012 2:16 am
by jcathunter
Al, I've also got a full trigg that trees HARD if another dog locates. If I could get him to locate, you are right, he'd be tough to beat. He'll put the fear of God in a cat given the chance.

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Tue Feb 07, 2012 3:32 am
by dwalton
I do not worry about a dog treeing until they reach 18 to 24 months old. Good locating dogs just get better with age. The ones that do it young usually I go to to many trees with nothing up. The dogs that look great at a year old for me usually don't get any better than what you see then. I like a young to progress slower then most people but these dogs to me will be able to lead at 2 to 3 years old. If your 2 and 3 year old dogs are not leading the races ahead of your 5 and 6 year old you had better be look for different dogs to run. I do not let a dog wander at a tree. If a young dog does or goes down the back track it gets shocked. As many young dogs as I hunt I will not tolerate not being close to the tree. It is OK not to bark treed but not OK to leave. They need to have enough track smarts to know that the track ended and that is the key, those are the ones that will tree in the long run. I want dogs that will open on a clean track and moving it not at any other time. If you have a pack that does that you will be surprised at how fast they move a track and how short your jumps are. In good winter conditions you should not be having over a 20 minute jump race in this area. There is always the exceptions, bluffs, roads, wind falls that will effect the length of the jump. Ever time your dogs make a loose on a jumped race your odds of treeing that cat just got cut in 1\2, next loose 1\4... If the cat ever gets a chance to get a breather he is going to get hard to tree. As far as locating tree dogs on bobcat if you have one consider yourself lucky. Dewey

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Tue Feb 07, 2012 12:06 pm
by BlazeNBrat
Dewey, I read your post and found alot of what you discribed to be very true in my own experence as well. Good post!

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Tue Feb 07, 2012 2:59 pm
by al baldwin
Dewey I agree with a lot of your last post, especially about the locator. I just see the loses a little different. Loses are part of cat hunting, & good packs that are hunted steady just find a way to over come them, and never worried about the time it took to catch. I will take a steady grinder over a speedster anyday, but a comination of the two forsure is the best situation. Having said that, must say easier said than done And doubt I will ever be able to hunt steady enough to own such a pack again.. Thanks for the discussion. Al

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Wed Feb 08, 2012 3:50 am
by dwalton
Al: In the past I have caught a lot of cats with steady not fast dogs that make all the corners. I would like a dog like that today. They seem to be the better locating tree dogs also. To me cats are far easier to tree than most people believe. It is very hard if you or your dog has not hunted them or treed them before. You have caught enough cats in you younger days to have seen it all the good cat dogs and the dogs that seldom tree a cat. Looses happen with cat hunting but I have seen a few dogs in my life that did not or seldom made a loose on cats. Once I hunted with a near perfect cat dog it is a tough measuring stick for the rest of the dogs to be compared to to. I don't have that today in a dog but I have close to that in a pack of dogs. It has been far easier for me to have a pack that will do it than to wait for that perfect dog that may never show up.I have a great pack of dogs but do not have that perfect cat dog. I finally got another litter of pups on the ground out of Pepper just let you know your old Skinner dog has some great grand kids.Dewey

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2012 12:19 am
by al baldwin
Dewey good luck with those pups. Thinking back pepper has most of local cat & old bear hunters blood in her.

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Wed Feb 15, 2012 12:23 am
by david
Wow great thread. Mr C. John Clay mentioned it too me as a good one, and he was not kidding. For some reason, my computer will not let me see the names of who is posting, so it was fun reading it to see if I could figure out each person by their views. It was a pretty cool exercise really. (But on the other hand, if some one can tell me how to make my computer let me see the names, let me know. :wink: ) The ones who signed their names made it a little easier.
al baldwin wrote: Thinking back pepper has most of local cat & old bear hunters blood in her. Zip Fendrich, Sam Faulk, Robin Powell, Von Beck, JC Freeman, Willis Sutton, Kevin Humpries, Wendell Smith, Doug Brooks, Jim Howell & I know you had a very good registered female some place back there. Al
Man, Mr Baldwin, some of those names and dogs are going back the 25 years or so when I was living in Oregon. Sam Faulk made an outcross on the McKenzie River Banjo dog I Brought to Oregon from Missouri. And Doug Brooks had a pup out of BanjoXRainbow. I can almost think of her name, but not quite. Many times I have wondered what became of Doug. I did not know him well, but he seemed like a fine young man. This is the first time I have seen his name mentioned in the twenty some years I have been gone from there. I was blessed also to be able to hunt with the "very good registered female" Dewey had back then: Pewee!

Those were all very powerful tree dogs. It is so interesting to see the pendulum swing again. Dogs on the Northwest were in a similar state when I bought those puppys from Mac Mcallister to bring with me home to Oregon. I was completely shocked and overwhelmed with a tidal wave of hunters from throughout the west who kept offering more and more money for pups from those two dogs. You would be surprised at some of the names who got dogs from me. I am! I really wanted to keep some for myself. I was so poor, making a very small wage as a preacher and putting my wife through college. I just could not afford to keep them because people kept offering more and more. I just took it as God providing a way for us to make it through. There was no other way I could figure out to stay out of real financial trouble, and even legal trouble. It was a strange phenomenon that I could not have in any way produced my self.

So here we are again with the same situation. Everything goes in cycles. I will tell you first hand, there are people that will come from very far away and beat a path to your door if you (accidentally or intentionally) fill a real need that exists in the hound world. If you are looking for a real need in the hound world, Well, Mr Jcathunter has clearly identified it for you.

Putting tree into bobcat dogs is a like trying to cut a diamond. It is a very complex issue with many facets. If one facet is out of balance, then the one next to it is thrown off as well. If you swing the jewelers hammer a little too hard, the thing breaks down the middle. I have always had strong tree dogs, but they bring with them so many problems that I get tired of it. I could easily be persuaded to wait two years or more for a dog to show me any tree if these problems could be avoided. For me, the core of all of the issues that come with powerful tree dogs is this:
The instinct is so strong that it does not involve enough thought. In fact, it eliminates thought.

So many of these dogs are unable to overcome their instincts with intelligent thought. This lack of ability to overcome instinct infiltrates every other aspect of the dogs hunting ability. You have heard this so much it is cliche', but a bobcat dog must be able to keep learning and learning and learning. This is the same thing Dewey was talking about when he said the dogs that are so amazing as young tree dogs are at their peak at a very young age. They pour it on early and peak out because they are not really able to learn. They look so good so young because they do not have to learn it, they are doing it by instinct. They are amazing, and they make everybody smile. They make everybody want one. They are very easy to sell at a very young age to bear hunters and coon hunters and lion hunters.

I remember loosing a bunch of friends on here the last time I talked about this. Here is what I said that was so offensive, (I guess I must be feeling like I have too many friends again):

When people are unable to overcome instinct with rational thought, they are called "prison convicts". When dogs are unable to overcome instinct with rational thought, they are called "Treeing Walkers".

As much as I love them and have always had a few, or at least hunted with a few, I hate em too. Great, great dogs that are nearly perfect at what their absolute genius breeders bred them to do. They were not bred to catch bobcats. They are used for that, but they were never intended for that at their very foundation. It shows.

I wish all the best to those trying to find that amazing balance. I watch with great interest, anticipation and hope.

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Wed Feb 15, 2012 1:19 am
by dwalton
I expect a young dog to tree at 18 to 24 months and not any sooner. The ones that tree young almost always tree to quick as they get older. I am surprised that a cat jumps out in this country. I have never had one do that. Are you shocking him for leaving the tree? Take him back to the tree and show him the cat. You have to stop him from milling at the tree. Do you have someone to hunt with that has a good locating tree dog. He needs to make the association that the track ends and the cat trees. Good locating tree dogs tree because of there track ability, they know that that track stop and now it is time to look for a tree, it does not come from being good tree dogs on cat, treeing comes from knowing that that track stopped. What is the breeding on this dog? Dewey

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Wed Feb 15, 2012 2:00 am
by al baldwin
David never heard of you. Thought Bill Dwyer brought Mckenzie River Banjo to Oregon. Recall when Sam made that cross. Don,t believe my old male had blood from that cross. Sam bred his old Wendy female to a son of the bell female I wrote about in another post. I had a male from that cross & bred that male to a female from a different cross sam made useing his breeding into the House line. The Mckenzie river blood came from a cross Wendell Smith made useing a female I gave him bred to Mckenzie River Hunter. Robin Powell trained & own hunter. I had hunted with Hunter notice he had an exceptional nose, moved a cold track very well, gave lots of voice on track, hustled hard and boxed good. I suggested Wendell make that crossed. Wound up with a male that lived to be 14+ and I never considered selling. Some may have not considered feeding him , but, I consider him the most balanced hound I have owned. Anyway hope some of this makes sense & you enjoy reading. Al

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Wed Feb 15, 2012 2:56 am
by dwalton
AL: Doug bought a dog he called Rusty from Bill Dwyer that I think was the Banjo dog. Robin Powell Hunter dogs was out of Rusty and Sadie from Doug Brooks. Sadie was out of Peewee and another Finley River bred dog. I think this is right, JC Freeman or Zip would know for sure. Dewey

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Wed Feb 15, 2012 4:07 pm
by al baldwin
Dewey, believe you are correct. Had a pedigree on hunter at one time, think it was 5 generation, believe Finley River Chief show up six times. Also believe pepper has a bunch of chief breeding on her dad side. Al

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Wed Feb 15, 2012 7:39 pm
by david
al baldwin wrote:David never heard of you. Thought Bill Dwyer brought Mckenzie River Banjo to Oregon. Recall when Sam made that cross. Al
Al, Mac Mcallister gave me first pick out of Banjo's litter, only because I was the first one to get there at weaning time. He was obviously different than the others in his litter. He strutted around like he owned that litter and the pen they were in. In fact his arrogance would probably include Macs immaculate farm and home. Finley River Banjo had just been killed by a car, and this was one of his last litters on earth. Little Banjo was 400.00 which was far beyond what my new wife and I could afford. I spent much time laying awake trying to figure out what his full name would be. As we were getting in the car to leave after spending the night hunting and sleeping, Mac picked up a female pup that was running around his farm and said, "here you are going to need something to breed that dog to." That was Rainbow.

My parents were keeping Banjo in their back yard for me while I finished college. I could not keep both dogs together in town because they got each other barking. One day when he was about 6 months old or so, my mom calls me at school and says I need to come over to their house as banjo has been barking steady for two hours or more and she cant get him to quit barking. My mom and dad knew nothing of hounds and hunting. I said mom, look at him what is he doing, tell me exactly what he is doing. So she goes to the sliding glass doors and says "well he has his feet on a telephone pole and just barking his head off." "MOM! look up the telephone pole." "Oh, hey, there is a squirrell up there at the top of it". I was so elated. He had been treeing for two hours or more. Mom was not happy at all as they lived right in residential Eugene. It took me another two hours to get there, and when I did he was still hammering every breath. Why that squirrel did not leave, I have no idea. His voice was tremendously loud but it is hard to imagine the squirrel being frozen that long. If you ever saw that dog on a bear, you know he never ever paused to swallow. His tree barks were steady. That is why he was always blowing his voice out.

I figured it was time to go to the woods with him. Rainbow was a month or two older so I figured she must be ready too. I was new at this but read everything I could about it. I took them to the woods that night. Rainbow treed her first coon that night with no help. She held that tree while Banjo ran trash around her all night. I kept thinking he would finally come in to her, but he had no intention of it. I would leave her when ever he got close to try and catch him. She never pulled from that tree. I was dumb enough to think that is just the way dogs are.

I thought he was running deer back then, but now I think it might have been a fox because every so often through the night he would come back through still blowing every time he hit the ground. There was no chance of catching him. I had no idea what to do. I tried all night to catch him and he never showed a sign of slowing down or getting tired.

I had to leave to get to classes, and just hoped some one would find him and call me from the name tag. I went to classes and came back in the afternoon, and he was still running wide open. Now, I could see though, so was able to put an angle on him and run him down.

I read an article by Bill Dwyer in Full Cry. He lived in Springfeild and listed his number with the article so I called him. I told him about my problems and he invited me to take him and his two dogs with me when I go. He was as poor as I was and welcomed the ride to the woods. I remember his male was named "Guy", I forgot the females name. They were what he called the "Emerald Valley" dogs out of Joe and Rainey. It is funny that "Joe and Rainey" could have easily been nick names for banJOE and Rainbow.

I remember in the phone conversation he asked me over and over to recite the pedigree of those two dogs. It was as if he just could not get enough of hearing it. He did that for the first few times we hunted together. He asked me if he could take Banjo and put him on bear so I said yes. Then he came back and asked me to give him half ownership for hunting him on bear. I said yes to that also. As soon as I did, and he started hunting him with other hunters I started getting phone calls from guys trying to under cut Bill. You can not believe all the warnings I got about Bill and how he took me so bad. I still don't think he did. You or any one else never would have heard of the dog if not for Bill. He had a tremendously hard time with me hunting my dog, however, and we ended up selling him. He went to Terry Merritt in New York for more money than I had ever held in my hand or bank account in my entire life. Again, that would not have happened if not for the way Bill "promoted" his dogs.

So you can see how very little I had to do with how things turned out. My only claim is to the months of research I did on the treeing walker breed to find what I believed would be the best cross in the world. That truly was my goal, and maybe I was not far off for that time in history.

Many bobcats were caught with those dogs and their offspring, but they were about the worst bobcat dogs I have had in my life of bobcat hunting. I never caught a single bobcat with Banjo in the heavily brushed upper coast range. I caught about 2% of the cats I had Rainbow on up there. That is, until I brought in a bobcat bred dog from Earl Davis. I did very well with the Missouri bred coon dogs on bobcat in the Cascades and high desert. I very seldom could get there though.

All this to say I became painfully aware of the problems powerful tree dogs can bring to the bobcat hunting table. I have learned from folks like Johnny Young and Jcathunter that the power of those genetics was still being noticed when I first found this board about 7 years ago. That is over 20 years later.

I love to go to a hard treeing dog. It is a huge part of the pleasure of the hunting experience for me. It means so much to have a dog that you know will be there treeing hard even if it takes you 8 hours to get there. It is so great to be able to stop at any moment in the long hard climb, or descent, or crawl through the brush. You know you will not have to stand there waiting to hear something. You just stop enough to hear, and there they are calling you on, giving you that encouragement to keep going; giving you that shot of adrenaline that you really need at that moment. These are tremendous moments in the life of a person who hunts bobcats.

I wont start on all the problems these dogs bring with them. If I did, I would have to give equal time to all the new problems rational thinking dogs bring with them also.

Jcathunter, dont give up on your search. I am sure the dogs you are looking for are out there in that very state you live in. Let us know how your search is going.

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Wed Feb 15, 2012 9:18 pm
by al baldwin
David great reading. Yes there certainley has been a lot of different blood put into the skinner dog that I owned. And he sure was not perfect, did have to kick butt for a false tree once in a while. Also treed some that on one else located on after I sold cody. Treed numerous he struck from the box that others did not know existed, also got out ran or out smarted by lots of cats. But no dog I ever owned or hunted him with out hussled him. And after about 4 years old, don,t remember anything out cold trailing him. Do not believe he or any other dogs I,ve hunted with could trail & catch a 24 hr. old bobcat track, unless the cat happen to feed around and lay up. I believe most of the cat tracks we catch are not near as old as some think. I grew up in Virginia untill 14 and used to lay wake at night & listen to an old fox hunters dogs run, Knew then I wanted to own a good hound. I have trailed toms a long was to jump. But how does one determine if that cat traveled hrs. ago or is just 1 hr ahead & looking for a female. Also a good place to add the female wendell smith bred to get skinner, I GAVE TO HIM AS A PUP & HE TRAINED HER. Thanks AL

Re: Doesn't anyone breed for locating and treeing these days

Posted: Thu Feb 16, 2012 1:44 am
by david
Al, I am glad you got something out of it, because it truely was written for you. I probably should have found where i had told it before and sent it in a pm to you. The board kind of goes in cycles I have noticed over the years. I never know how much to repeat stuff when folks ask.
al baldwin wrote: no dog I ever owned or hunted him with out hussled him. And after about 4 years old, don,t remember anything out cold trailing him.

I grew up in Virginia untill 14 and used to lay wake at night & listen to an old fox hunters dogs run, Knew then I wanted to own a good hound.
Thanks AL


Skinner sounds like as fine a hound as any man could hope to own.

I sure have noticed that a lot of the best houndsmen have ties to the South and South east some where in their family or background. The same is true of virtually all our hounds and curs, as far as I know. I sure wish the places I have lived understood the hound as well as places like Virginia. Funny that I am sitting in Virginia right now as I write this. Wish i could hear some hounds.

It is fun reading about your hounds and your life. Be blessed.